A heat pump should be sized from a load calculation on your house, which the trade calls Manual J, and not from the size of the unit being hauled away. ENERGY STAR puts the stakes plainly: a system that is either too large or too small for its space will struggle to meet your comfort needs.
What "size" means
Size is capacity: how much heat the equipment can move in an hour. It has nothing to do with the dimensions of the cabinet. Capacity that matches the house runs long, steady cycles. Capacity that overshoots the house satisfies the thermostat fast and shuts off, again and again.
Why the old unit is a bad guide
The unit in your yard was sized for the house as it was on the day it went in, by whoever put it in, using whatever method they used. Since then the house may have new windows, more attic insulation, a sealed-up chimney or an added room. And plenty of original installs were sized by rule of thumb in the first place.
Duct leaks muddy it further. ENERGY STAR says that in a typical house about 20 to 30 percent of the air moving through the duct system is lost to leaks, holes and poorly connected ducts. A system that seemed too small may have been delivering a quarter of its output to the attic. Fix the ducts and the right equipment size can drop.
What a load calculation looks at
ENERGY STAR describes Manual J as "a calculation of the amount of heating and cooling your home requires to keep you warm in the winter and cool in the summer", and says your contractor should use it to verify the proper size. In practice the contractor measures or collects:
- floor area and ceiling heights, room by room
- window sizes, types and which way they face
- insulation levels in the attic, walls and floor
- how leaky the house is
- the local design temperatures for summer and winter
The result is two numbers, a cooling load and a heating load. In most of Texas the cooling load picks the equipment. Farther north the heating load does, and that is where the next question comes in.
Cold weather and backup heat
A heat pump's output falls as the outdoor temperature drops, so sizing for heating means deciding what covers the coldest hours. ENERGY STAR's cold climate certification requires third-party verified performance at low temperatures, testing down to 5 degrees Fahrenheit. It notes that a cold climate unit keeps working below that, but that pairing it with a backup energy source heats the home most efficiently.
One sensible arrangement where there is already a good gas furnace is dual fuel: the heat pump carries the mild days and the furnace takes over in deep cold. ENERGY STAR describes that as a modest extra cost over installing an AC alone.
Installation counts as much as the box
Size is only the first half. ENERGY STAR warns that improper installation can reduce system efficiency by up to 30 percent. A correctly sized unit on undersized return ducts, or charged with the wrong amount of refrigerant, will run like the wrong unit. Ask what the installer checks at start-up, and ask to see the numbers.
What to ask for
- "Will you run a Manual J on my house, and can I have a copy?" A contractor who sizes from the old nameplate alone has skipped the step.
- "What did you assume about my ducts?" If nobody looked in the attic, the answer is a guess.
- "What is the backup heat and when does it come on?"
- "Which license covers this job?" In Texas a house system falls under a TDLR air conditioning contractor license with the Environmental Air endorsement. Class B covers cooling systems of 25 tons and under, which is far more than any house needs.