A storage tank keeps a batch of water hot around the clock. A tankless heater fires only when a tap opens. A heat pump water heater moves heat out of the surrounding air into a tank. The right one depends less on the brochure and more on three things in your house: the fuel you have, the room the heater sits in, and how many taps run at once.
How each type makes hot water
| Type | How it works | What it asks of the house |
|---|---|---|
| Storage tank | Heats a tank of water and holds it at temperature until you use it. | Floor space, a flue if it burns gas, and a drain pan and relief line. |
| Gas tankless | ENERGY STAR describes it this way: when a hot tap opens, cold water is drawn into the heater, a flow sensor activates the gas burner, and the water leaves the heat exchanger at its set temperature. | A gas line and venting sized for a burner that fires hard for short periods. |
| Heat pump (hybrid) | Works like a refrigerator in reverse: it takes heat from the surrounding air and transfers it to water in a tank. In heavy demand it switches to standard electric resistance heat, which is why it is sold as a hybrid. | A room that stays between 40 and 90 degrees Fahrenheit year-round with about 1,000 cubic feet of air around the unit, plus a condensate drain. |
Where tankless earns its keep
The saving with tankless comes from one place. ENERGY STAR puts it simply: these heaters save energy by heating water only when needed, eliminating energy lost during standby operation. If your tank sits hot all day while the house is empty, that standby loss is what you are paying for now.
What tankless does not do is make hot water arrive at the tap any faster, and a single unit has a ceiling on how much it can heat at once. Before you buy, count the fixtures that realistically run together in your house on a winter morning and have the installer size to that, not to the number of bathrooms.
Where a heat pump water heater fits, and where it does not
A heat pump water heater pulls heat from the room it stands in, so the room matters as much as the unit. ENERGY STAR says to install one in an interior space that stays between 40 and 90 degrees Fahrenheit all year and provides 1,000 cubic feet of air space around the heater. It also says these units generally do not operate as efficiently in colder spaces and can cool the spaces they are in.
In a Texas garage that is good news for much of the year: ENERGY STAR notes that during hot humid times the heater can help cool and dehumidify the space. A tight interior closet is the wrong spot unless the door is louvered or the unit is ducted. If you have a furnace room with spare heat, ENERGY STAR suggests considering that.
The control panel will offer modes. Efficiency or Economy runs the heat pump only. Auto or Hybrid, the default, lets the electric elements help when demand is high. Leave it in hybrid until you know how your household uses it.
The install is plumbing work, and usually a permit
In Texas, the Plumbing License Law requires a municipality with more than 5,000 inhabitants to regulate the "material, construction, alteration, and inspection" of water heaters along with pipes and fixtures. The same section lists the small jobs that do not need a plumbing permit: repairing leaks, replacing faucets, ballcocks or water control valves, garbage disposals, and toilets. A water heater is not on that list.
The law also carves water heaters out of the exemption that lets appliance dealers hook up appliances: dealers may connect appliances to existing openings "other than installation and service work on water heaters". In short, swapping a water heater in a Texas city is a job for a plumbing company working under a Responsible Master Plumber, with a permit and an inspection. Ask who is pulling the permit before the old tank is drained.
Five questions for the quote
- What is the Responsible Master Plumber's license number, and is the permit in the price?
- For tankless: is my gas line big enough, and where will the vent run?
- For a heat pump unit: does the room meet the air space and temperature range, and where does the condensate go?
- What happens to the old heater?
- Is anything else being brought up to code, such as the drain pan or relief line, and is that in the price?