ENERGY STAR's prompts are an air conditioner or heat pump more than 10 years old, or a furnace or boiler more than 15. Those are reasons to start getting prices, not orders to replace. A ten-year-old system that has had one cheap repair is in a different place from one on its third compressor.
The signs ENERGY STAR lists
- Your heat pump or air conditioner is more than 10 years old.
- Your furnace or boiler is more than 15 years old.
- Your equipment needs frequent repairs and your energy bills are going up.
- Some rooms are too hot or too cold.
- Your home has humidity problems.
Look at the last two again. ENERGY STAR itself says uneven rooms can come from improper equipment operation, duct problems or inadequate insulation, and humidity problems from poor equipment operation, inadequate equipment or leaky ductwork. New equipment bolted to the same leaky ducts will give you the same hot back bedroom. Have the ducts looked at before you decide the box is the problem.
What new equipment saves
ENERGY STAR's figures: a certified heat pump or air conditioner, installed correctly, can save up to 20 percent on heating and cooling costs, and a certified furnace is 15 percent more efficient than a conventional one. For a sense of scale, it says heating and cooling is almost half the average household's annual energy bill, more than $900 a year.
Do that arithmetic honestly for your own house. Twenty percent of your yearly heating and cooling spend is the most a new system can return, and only if the install is done right. Against that, weigh the price difference between the repair and the replacement.
How the refrigerant rules change a repair quote
If your system uses R-410A, you may hear that it "cannot be repaired any more". That is not what the EPA says. Its guidance is that homeowners can maintain and repair their systems throughout the useful life of the equipment, and can replace a faulty component such as a condensing unit or indoor coil with a similar R-410A component.
What has changed is the whole-system swap. Replace both the outdoor unit and the indoor coil together and the EPA counts it as a new system, which must use a lower-GWP refrigerant. So the real choices on a failed outdoor unit are a like-for-like R-410A outdoor unit, or a complete new matched system on the newer refrigerant. The EPA does caution that R-410A and its components may become less available over time, which is a fair thing to weigh on a system that is already old. Our refrigerant guide goes through it.
A way to think it through
| Question | Leans toward repair | Leans toward replace |
|---|---|---|
| How old is it? | Under ENERGY STAR's 10 and 15 year marks | Well past them |
| What failed? | A capacitor, contactor, fan motor, igniter or drain | The compressor or a leaking coil on an old system |
| Repair history? | First real repair | Frequent repairs and rising bills |
| Was the house ever comfortable with it? | Yes, until it broke | No, and the ducts have been checked |
If you do replace
The install is where the money is won or lost. ENERGY STAR says improper installation can reduce system efficiency by up to 30 percent. Three things to insist on:
- A load calculation, not a copy of the old unit's size. See sizing basics.
- A look at the ducts, with any sealing priced into the job.
- The contractor's license number, checked. In Texas that is a TDLR air conditioning contractor license with the Environmental Air endorsement.
And if a single visit produces a verdict that the whole system has to go today, get a second licensed contractor to look. A good diagnosis survives a second opinion.